We're reading EB White's Trumpet of the Swan for school right now. I haven't read this story since I was young, but I remember absolutely loving it. I've been wanting to read it to the boys for awhile. I had totally forgotten that the main character, Sam Beaver was from Montana and much of the story takes place here. Small world, I guess. The other day we were reading from chapter 4 where the cob begins one of his long, drawn-out babbling speeches. In this one he's talking about fatherhood ...
"Here I glide, swanlike," he said, "while earth is bathed in wonder and beauty. Now, slowly, the light of day comes into our sky. A mist hangs low over the pond. The mist rises slowly, like steam from a kettle, while I glide, swanlike, while eggs hatch, while young swans come into existence. I glide and glide, swanlike. Birds sing their early song. Frogs that have croaked in the night stop croaking and are silent. Still I glide, ceaselessly, like a swan."
I stop to reflect on what I just read. There's something odd about that paragraph. I ask the boys, "How would a swan know what a kettle is?" They both look at me and Nathan replies, "Maybe he looks in windows when he's flying." Oh dear. That struck me funny and I cracked up laughing. Hmmm, maybe they do. Come to think of it, I've had turkeys looking in my windows. I've had bears press their nose up on my glass doors. I know the squirrels have seen me and a few times I've been chuffed at through the window by deer outside. I can't say I've seen any swans watching me fire up the tea kettle, but hey, anything is possible, especially in Montana!
They're watching yoooooooouuuu.
ReplyDeleteO_O
But seriously...I loved this book as a kid. And I totally forgot about the kettle part. That is silly!
Gale
I loved this book as a kid too....a teacher read it to the class. I loved it again when I read it to my oldest. I think it's time to read it to dtr #2. (We're reading ANIMAL FAMILY right now)
ReplyDeleteI don't think I have ever heard of this book and yet the author sounds SO familiar - I am going to have to go Google them!
ReplyDeleteSounds perfectly reasonable to me that the swan knows what a kettle is... now if it had said perculator - well that would have been strange. lol
Duh... Charlotte's Web of course! (Did I mention it is late, everyone is sick and I am tired?) No excuse but it's all I have! lol
ReplyDeleteI have never read this book,but now I must get a copy.I really liked Nathan's answer too. He's a good thinker!
ReplyDeleteLeanne
I TOTALLY forgot about that book...wow..memories...I'm going to have to pick up a copy of that. Seriously.
ReplyDeleteNow I've got another book on my list.
ReplyDeletePlus, it's always fun to read a book set in your own hometown'ish place.
:)
It's not a question that would have struck me, but how indeed? Maybe in those days, in those parts, there were gypsies on the lake shore? I know, I'm really stretching there.
ReplyDeleteWhat a coincidence - my son is re-reading this book and we were just discussing it.
ReplyDeleteLOL at the animals peeking in the windows...I think they mostly wonder where we stash the food.
Well Rena, if a swan can talk certain he would know about kettles! :O
ReplyDeleteI read this book a while back while going through my stacks of must read books. I found it enjoyable actually and got taken into the story. A quick fun read.
ReplyDelete