Sunday, January 25, 2009

Do swans look in windows?

We're reading EB White's Trumpet of the Swan for school right now. I haven't read this story since I was young, but I remember absolutely loving it. I've been wanting to read it to the boys for awhile. I had totally forgotten that the main character, Sam Beaver was from Montana and much of the story takes place here. Small world, I guess. The other day we were reading from chapter 4 where the cob begins one of his long, drawn-out babbling speeches. In this one he's talking about fatherhood ...

"Here I glide, swanlike," he said, "while earth is bathed in wonder and beauty. Now, slowly, the light of day comes into our sky. A mist hangs low over the pond. The mist rises slowly, like steam from a kettle, while I glide, swanlike, while eggs hatch, while young swans come into existence. I glide and glide, swanlike. Birds sing their early song. Frogs that have croaked in the night stop croaking and are silent. Still I glide, ceaselessly, like a swan."

I stop to reflect on what I just read. There's something odd about that paragraph. I ask the boys, "How would a swan know what a kettle is?" They both look at me and Nathan replies, "Maybe he looks in windows when he's flying." Oh dear. That struck me funny and I cracked up laughing. Hmmm, maybe they do. Come to think of it, I've had turkeys looking in my windows. I've had bears press their nose up on my glass doors. I know the squirrels have seen me and a few times I've been chuffed at through the window by deer outside. I can't say I've seen any swans watching me fire up the tea kettle, but hey, anything is possible, especially in Montana!

11 comments:

  1. They're watching yoooooooouuuu.

    O_O

    But seriously...I loved this book as a kid. And I totally forgot about the kettle part. That is silly!

    Gale

    ReplyDelete
  2. I loved this book as a kid too....a teacher read it to the class. I loved it again when I read it to my oldest. I think it's time to read it to dtr #2. (We're reading ANIMAL FAMILY right now)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I don't think I have ever heard of this book and yet the author sounds SO familiar - I am going to have to go Google them!

    Sounds perfectly reasonable to me that the swan knows what a kettle is... now if it had said perculator - well that would have been strange. lol

    ReplyDelete
  4. Duh... Charlotte's Web of course! (Did I mention it is late, everyone is sick and I am tired?) No excuse but it's all I have! lol

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have never read this book,but now I must get a copy.I really liked Nathan's answer too. He's a good thinker!

    Leanne

    ReplyDelete
  6. I TOTALLY forgot about that book...wow..memories...I'm going to have to pick up a copy of that. Seriously.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Now I've got another book on my list.

    Plus, it's always fun to read a book set in your own hometown'ish place.

    :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. It's not a question that would have struck me, but how indeed? Maybe in those days, in those parts, there were gypsies on the lake shore? I know, I'm really stretching there.

    ReplyDelete
  9. What a coincidence - my son is re-reading this book and we were just discussing it.

    LOL at the animals peeking in the windows...I think they mostly wonder where we stash the food.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Well Rena, if a swan can talk certain he would know about kettles! :O

    ReplyDelete
  11. I read this book a while back while going through my stacks of must read books. I found it enjoyable actually and got taken into the story. A quick fun read.

    ReplyDelete